Global air cargo decline could again be an unwelcome portent for passenger demand
On many occasions a decline in air cargo volume has foreshadowed one in the passenger segment.
With airlines trying desperately to provide capacity to fulfil the schedules they hastily put in place as the pandemic began to wane, any such further downturn would be disastrous, and there are many external factors in play which collectively, or even individually, could drive down demand.
The Apr-2022 statistics that show cargo volume falls in each of the six world regions, load factor falls in five, and capacity falls in four of them, will hopefully turn out to be a blip.
If they are not, then airlines might start to think seriously about further passenger flight capacity cuts for the remainder of the year and beyond.
- International passenger demand is in fairly good shape right now – although a week is an even longer time in the air transport business than it is in politics.
- But air cargo statistics do not make for good reading, and often that means those for passengers will soon follow suit.
- Inflation, high fuel prices and low consumer confidence will dictate industry trends in the next year.
- The Ukraine war has had a greater impact on the cargo segment than on passengers.
International passenger segment in comparatively good health
Historically in the air transport business a downturn in cargo demand and activity is all too frequently a precursor to much the same happening in the passenger segment.
There are early signs of such a cargo downturn, so such an outcome could be on the cards. That is the last thing the industry wants after two years of chaos followed by more turmoil as it attempts to recruit staff to replace those fired during the COVID-19 pandemic, amid a myriad of other problems.
According to the latest reports issued by the International Air Transport Association (IATA), the passenger segment is in reasonably good health, meaning it is out of the intensive care ward but still in high dependency.
The industry body reports (Jun-2022) that global air travel "resumed its strong recovery trend" in Apr-2022, driven primarily by international demand, despite the war in Ukraine and continuing travel restrictions in China.
Global Revenue Passenger Kilometres (RPKs) increased by +78.7% year-on-year in Apr-2022, which was slightly ahead of the +76% growth recorded in Mar-2022.
Domestic travel decrease dictated by events in China
Domestic passenger travel decreased by -1%, a reversal from the +10.6% increase in Mar-2022.
But IATA insisted that the result "was driven entirely by continuing strict travel restrictions in China", where domestic traffic decreased by -80.8% but where there has been a dramatic recovery in domestic seat capacity – almost a doubling of it – since the end of May-2022, when some of those restrictions were eased (green line on chart below).
China: weekly total domestic seat capacity, 2019-2022* (projected)
International RPKs increased by +331.9%, which was a notable acceleration from the +289.9% growth in Mar-2022.
New flexible entry conditions in previously restricted Asian countries allowed for foreign arrivals, fostering higher growth rates in the region.
However, the divergence in the pace of the recovery between Asia Pacific and other markets persists.
Events of concern include inflation, high fuel prices and low consumer confidence
IATA noted inflation as one of several "points of concern for the coming months."
In the latter two cases that is hyperinflation (over 50%), and there are presently eight countries in that predicament. They will assuredly be joined by others before long. Strangely, China has the lowest inflation rate of developed countries (2.1%). The highest is Venezuela at 222%. (Source: Trading Economics).
Other points of concern naturally include high fuel prices.
On 10-Jun-2022 a barrel of Brent Crude was trading at USD123.5, not the highest ever (that was USD147 in Jul-2008), but worryingly close to it and still going up.
Also ‘low consumer confidence’, which is a function of the factors mentioned above.
In the UK, where this article is written, media reports suggest that “nightmare” queues at airports to clear security at one end of a journey or to clear Border Control and retrieve baggage at the other, together with flight cancellations and delays being measured in days rather than hours, topped off with anticipated airfare increases of +70% in the summer of 2022 – all mean that for many the ‘staycation’ will again take priority this year.
This brings into question IATA’s assertion that international bookings "show a high willingness to travel abroad" and that the positive trend is expected to continue throughout the 2022 northern summer.
The traffic figures have certainly been much better as many travel restrictions were lifted, but that should not necessarily be taken as a definitive indicator of future trends.
Other health-related events waiting in the wings?
In such circumstances another unexpected blow can have severe repercussions for recovering demand.
For example, the World Health Organisation, which is attempting to take over global responsibility from sovereign nations for setting disease control parameters (including travel restrictions and ‘lockdowns’), began talking recently about "washing your hands frequently, avoiding contact with infected people and wearing a face mask", being measures to minimise the spread of monkeypox. Shades of Mar-2020.
Nevertheless, the passenger segment is without doubt in a better place than it was, with almost all statistics registering positive.
That isn’t the case, though, for the cargo segment.
Fall in global air cargo demand in line with expectations
IATA reports decreases in global air cargo demand and capacity in Apr-2022, driven by "a challenging operating backdrop" – again caused specifically by the effects of the COVID-19 Omicron variant in Asia and the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
New export orders, which are a leading indicator of cargo demand and world trade, are now shrinking in all markets except the US.
Global demand in Cargo Tonne Kilometres (CTKs) decreased by -11.2% year-on-year in Apr-2022. International CTKs decreased by -10.6%.
Compared to Apr-2019, demand decreased by -1%. In another words, cargo demand is decreasing at a greater rate compared to last year, when the coronavirus pandemic held a vice-like grip, than compared to the good times benchmark year of 2019.
Capacity also decreased by -2% year-on-year. Asia recorded the largest regional drops in capacity.
It isn’t just wheat and sunflower oil – Russian and Ukrainian airlines removed from the cargo supply chain
The conflict in Ukraine, which shows no sign of coming to any sort of conclusion and has degenerated further into a highly destructive war, led to a fall in cargo capacity serving Europe as several airlines based in Russia and Ukraine were key cargo players in the business. Supply chain disruptions due to the conflict are also adding to downward pressure on trade generally.
China’s never-ending 'zero COVID' policy has shattered cargo volume
The zero-COVID policy in China led to capacity challenges due to flight cancellations resulting from labour shortages. Lockdowns brought much of Shanghai to a standstill.
At the time of writing, lockdowns had been eased in that city for the first time in two months, but were then reintroduced in some suburbs, apparently in yet another fruitless attempt to achieve the aims of that policy.
Shanghai Pudong International Airport: annual traffic, cargo volume/growth, 2019-2022 (Jan-Apr)
New export orders are now shrinking in all markets except the US.
Global goods trade has continued to decline in 2022, with China's economy growing more slowly due to COVID-19 lockdowns and other factors.
Economic growth in China (GDP percentage), Mar-2019 to Mar-2022
Meanwhile, the agency revised its 2023 growth forecast slightly higher, to +5.2% from +5.1%, on the assumption that the government will phase out its ‘dynamic zero-COVID’ policy only gradually over the course of 2023.
IATA's Willie Walsh sees at least some cause for optimism
The operating environment is challenging for all businesses, he said, including air cargo, adding, “But with China easing lockdown restrictions, there was cause for some optimism and the supply/demand imbalance is keeping yields high". (I.e. higher fares – the next big turn-off for international travellers).