09-Jul-2013 3:54 PM

Aer Lingus’ Atlantic adventure tests the virtual airline concept

Analysis

In early Jul-2013, Aer Lingus CEO Christoph Mueller declared that the carrier was "back to growth mode" (Financial Times, 4-Jul-2013), driven by Atlantic expansion. After 13% capacity growth on the Atlantic in 2013, Aer Lingus is planning a remarkable 24% growth in 2014. An important element of this growth involves attracting transfer traffic originating in the UK regions away from London Heathrow, building on Dublin's geographic position and growing North American connectivity.

There are to be new routes from Dublin to San Francisco and Toronto and increased frequencies from Shannon to New York and Boston. A significant part of the new capacity will be operated under wet-lease by ASL Aviation Group. An important proportion of Aer Lingus' regional feed from the UK into Dublin is also operated by a third party (Aer Arann) and Aer Lingus itself operates short-haul flights for Virgin Atlantic.

With these moves Aer Lingus appears to be testing and developing the concept of a virtual airline.

Summary

Aer Lingus is experiencing growth in its transatlantic operations, with a focus on attracting transfer traffic from UK regions away from London Heathrow.
Dublin Airport has more weekly seat capacity to North America than any UK airport apart from Heathrow, offering 11 destinations in North America.
North America represents Dublin Airport's second most important region by seat capacity after Western Europe.
North America currently represents less than 10% of Aer Lingus' international seat capacity, but it is an area of growth for the airline.
Aer Lingus carried 100,000 UK passengers to the US via Dublin in 2012, making up over 20% of its US network passengers.
Aer Lingus plans to continue strong capacity growth in the Atlantic in 2014, with two new routes from Dublin and increased frequencies from Shannon to Boston and New York.

Dublin has more weekly seats to North America than any UK airport apart from Heathrow

London Heathrow has 30 North American destinations, including nine of the 11 served by Dublin, so it is likely to remain the first choice hub for the majority of UK travellers to North America. Nevertheless, for large parts of the UK, Dublin is a viable alternative to Heathrow.

Dublin Airport has more weekly seat capacity to North America than any UK airport apart from Heathrow (source: Innovata, week of 8-Jul-2013) and it offers 11 destinations in North America, the same as London Gatwick and one fewer than Manchester.

Dublin offers two destinations in North America (Boston and Charlotte) that do not have direct links with UK regional cities and five (Atlanta, Chicago, Montreal, Philadelphia and Washington) that have direct links with only one UK regional city. Dublin has one destination (Orlando) not offered by Heathrow.

UK and Ireland airports weekly seat capacity and number of destinations to North America: 8-Jul-2013 to 14-Jul-2013

Airport	Seats	Number of destination airports	Cities served*
Heathrow	433,165	30	Atlanta, Baltimore, Boston, Calgary, Charlotte Douglas, Chicago, Dallas Fort Worth, Denver, Detroit, Edmonton, Halifax, Houston, Las Vegas, Los Angeles, Miami, Minneapolis, Montreal, New York, Ottawa, Philadelphia, Phoenix, Raleigh Durham, San Diego, San Francisco, Seattle Tacoma, St John's, Toronto, Vancouver, Washington Dulles
Dublin	52,762	11	Atlanta, Boston, Charlotte Douglas, Chicago, Montreal, New York, Orlando, Philadelphia, Toronto, Washington Dulles
Gatwick	44,554	11	Bermuda, Calgary, Edmonton, Halifax, Las Vegas, Montreal, Orlando, Ottawa, Tampa, Toronto, Vancouver
Manchester	37,187	12	Atlanta, Calgary, Chicago, Las Vegas, New York, Orlando, Philadelphia, Toronto, Vancouver, Washington Dulles
Shannon	13,492	6	New York, Boston
Glasgow	12,372	7	Calgary, New York, Orlando, Philadelphia, Toronto, Vancouver
Edinburgh	6,042	2	New York, Toronto
Birmingham	2,892	2	New York, Toronto
LondonCity	352	1	New York

Dublin Airport's transatlantic passenger growth is outperforming

In 2012, Dublin Airport saw growth of 5% in the number of trans-Atlantic passengers, to more than 1.6 million. In the first five months of 2013, more than 600,000 passengers travelled between Dublin and North America, an 11% increase on last year. This is faster growth than the 4% experienced by the airport as a whole in the first five months of 2013. Although detailed numbers were not yet published, the airport said on 3-Jul-2013 that passenger numbers on trans-Atlantic services were up more than 10% for the first six months.

North America represents Dublin Airport's most important region by seat capacity after Western Europe, with just under 10% of international seats from the airport (source: Innovata, week of 8-Jul-2013). By country, the United Kingdom and the United States are the first and third most important international destinations by seat capacity to Dublin Airport. Between them, they account for 44% of Dublin's seats, suggesting strong potential to develop connecting flows.

Dublin Airport international seat capacity by region: 8-Jul-2013 to 14-Jul-2013

Dublin Airport international seat capacity by country: 8-Jul-2013 to 14-Jul-2013

North America accounts for less than 10% of Aer Lingus seats

North America currently represents less than 10% of Aer Lingus' international seat capacity and around 9% of its total seat capacity (source: Innovata, week of 8-Jul-2013), but it is an area of growth.

Aer Lingus international seat capacity by region: 8-Jul-2013 to 14-Jul-2013

UK-originating passengers are significant to Aer Lingus' North America network

In 2012, the Irish airline carried 100,000 UK passengers to the US via Dublin, or 200,000 on a two-way basis. This compares with a total of 981,000 passengers reported on the airline's long-haul network, which is exclusively to the US, meaning that just over 20% of passengers on its US network began their journey in the UK in 2012. Given a break-even passenger load factor of approaching 74% for the airline overall (source: CAPA analysis), these passengers make a significant contribution to Aer Lingus' profitability.

This strategy of targeting UK passengers builds on Dublin's geographical position, which places it to the west of all the major UK cities. The UK's main hub, London Heathrow, is located to the east of most of these cities. Aer Lingus flies from Dublin to New York JFK, Boston, Chicago and Orlando.

Aer Lingus routes from Dublin: 8-Jul-2013

Aer Lingus' growth is North America-focused

In 2013, Aer Lingus is focusing its growth on its US network, and on feeding UK passengers into it. In the first half of 2013 (Jan-Jul), the long-haul network saw growth in passenger numbers of 12.7%, compared with 1.3% for the airline overall. This growth on the long-haul (i.e. US) outstrips the growth on the North Atlantic at Dublin Airport overall, highlighting that Aer Lingus is accounting for most of the growth on this route region.

The number of UK passengers carried by Aer Lingus to the US via Dublin increased by 36% in the first six months of 2013. In summer 2013 (Mar-Oct), Aer Lingus is flying around 14,000 weekly seats to North America, an increase over summer 2012 of roughly 2,000 seats or 17%.

Ireland to North America (one way weekly seat capacity by carrier): 19-Sep-2011 to 29-Dec-2013

Two new Aer Lingus North American routes planned in 2014

Aer Lingus also plans to continue strong capacity growth in the Atlantic next year, with a 24% increase in its trans-Atlantic capacity in 2014 through two new routes from Dublin and increased frequencies from Shannon to Boston and New York. It will base two Boeing 757 aircraft, wet-leased from ASL Aviation Group's Irish airline Air Contractors, at Shannon. It plans to launch a daily 757 service to Toronto, also to be operated by Air Contractors, and to add San Francisco to the network in Apr-2014.

Air Contractors, the Dublin-based subsidiary of ASL Aviation Group, is a cargo specialist, but has operated passenger flights since 2010. It also provides charter services, ACMI contracts, consultancy and project management services.

The San Francisco route, using A330 equipment and operated by Aer Lingus five times weekly, builds on the links between Silicon Valley and the Irish capital, where a number of technology companies have their European headquarters. Toronto is home to a large Irish community and this route builds on Aer Lingus' strategy of connecting Ireland to the global Irish diaspora.

Using partner carriers in North America, Aer Lingus will offer customers travelling from a number of UK and European cities via Dublin onward connections to sixteen cities on the US west coast and beyond including Seattle, Los Angeles, Las Vegas and San Diego. Passengers travelling from UK and Europe via Dublin to Toronto will have the option to connect to eight key cities within Canada including Vancouver, Montreal and Calgary.

Aer Lingus has strong North American market positions

Aer Lingus has some strong market positions on its North American network and this serves to increase the likelihood that UK passengers will choose its service on these routes when connecting over Dublin. It is the number one carrier on all four of its existing North American routes from Dublin and the monopoly carrier on two of these (Boston and Orlando).

If existing competitors make no changes to their schedules, Aer Lingus will be a monopoly carrier on its planned new San Francisco route and have a similar weekly seat capacity to Air Canada on its new Toronto route. It also has a monopoly position on Shannon to Boston, but is currently only the third biggest carrier on Shannon to New York.

Aer Lingus competitive position on North American routes: 8-Jul-2013

	Aer Lingus rank by seats on route	Competitors (ranked by seats)
Dublin-New York JFK	1	1 Aer Lingus, 2 Delta, 3 AA, 4 United*
Dublin-Chicago	1	1 Aer Lingus, 2 AA
Dublin-Boston	1	Monopoly
Dublin-Orlando	1	Monopoly
Dublin-San Francisco	Apr-2014 launch	None currently
Dublin-Toronto	Apr-2014 launch	1 Air Canada, 2 Air Transat
Shannon-Boston	1	Monopoly
Shannon-New York JFK	3	1 Delta, 2 United*, 3 Aer Lingus

After the launch of the Toronto route in Apr-2014, there will still be five North American destinations that are served from Dublin by other carriers with no Aer Lingus presence: Atlanta, Charlotte Douglas, Montreal, Philadelphia and Washington Dulles. In addition, there are many routes not served from Dublin by any carrier, pointing to the potential for further growth.

Aer Lingus' North American growth strategy looks credible

Aer Lingus' trans-Atlantic growth strategy, partly based on taking market share of connecting passengers away from carriers based at Heathrow, looks credible given Dublin's geographic position and its improving North American connectivity. Nevertheless, to put it in context, Aer Lingus' approximately 14,000 weekly one-way seat capacity to North America this summer compares with British Airways' total of more than 90,000 seats from the UK to North America.

Aer Lingus is the number seven carrier by seat capacity from UK and Ireland to North America and the number 16 carrier from Europe to North America.

Ironically perhaps, this lack of scale for Aer Lingus may assist its growth, as a low percentage loss of transfer traffic for one of the big competitors translates into a significant percentage gain for Aer Lingus. It will have to manage potential conflicts with Virgin Atlantic, for whom it operates short-haul connecting flights from Manchester, Edinburgh and Aberdeen to its London hub.

Moreover, Aer Lingus will need to ensure operational consistency with its wet-lease partner on its long-haul routes. Nevertheless, this strategy certainly offers growth potential if these challenges can successfully be met.

United Kingdom to North America (one way weekly seat capacity by carrier): 19-Sep-2011 to 29-Dec-2013