Airline mergers: why Europe needs blue sky thinking
IAG's interest in acquiring Norwegian Air Shuttle once again focuses attention on the process of consolidation in the European aviation sector. Although often headline-grabbing, this is a process that has not led to any significant change in market structure in recent years.
The wave of mega-mergers in Europe started with Air France and KLM in 2004, included Lufthansa's acquisitions of SWISS and Austrian, and ended with the 2011 combination of British Airways and Iberia to form IAG. Since then, consolidation has ambled along at a slow pace, led by mergers of smaller scale and market exits.
By comparison with North America, Europe's aviation market remains very fragmented. Europe's top seven airline groups control 55% of seats to/from/within Europe in summer 2018, compared with an 82% share for North America's top seven.
An acquisition of Norwegian would add 3% to IAG's 9% share and take it just ahead of Lufthansa Group as Europe's number one. However, it would leave it well short of American Airlines' market-leading 19% share in North America and still leave Europe in a fragmented state.
Only mergers between Europe's biggest groups could match the seat share of North America's leading players.
- Europe's top seven seat share has gained 2.2ppts since summer 2015, but its 55.5% share is much less than the 81.8% for the top seven in North America.
- An IAG/Norwegian deal would create Europe's leading group, with 12% of seats, but would not take market structure much closer to North America's.
- Only mergers between Europe's biggest groups could match the seat share of leading players in North America, where American Airlines has 19%.
- Matching American's 19% share would require mergers such as Lufthansa Group/Air France-KLM, Ryanair/IAG, or Lufthansa Group/easyJet.
Concentration in Europe has changed little in recent years
There has been very little consolidation in Europe in recent years. In spite of the disappearance of airlines such as Transaero, Monarch, airberlin and Estonian Air, market concentration changed little between summer 2015 and summer 2018.
Transaero and Monarch each had less than 1% of total seats in Europe and Estonian Air only a tenth of this. Air Berlin Group was more significant, with approximately 3% of seats, but much of this capacity is now flying with the Lufthansa Group and easyJet.
As the chart below indicates, the share of seats held by the top 20 airline groups operating to/from/within Europe was 77.6% in summer 2015 and is 78.3% in summer 2018 – an increase of only 0.6ppts.
There are different ways of looking at concentration and there have been slightly greater increases in the seat share held by the top 10, top seven, top five and top three, but only by 2ppts or so in each case.
Europe: seat share of top 20, top 10, top seven, top five and top three airline groups, summer 2015 to summer 2018
Europe's top seven seat share has gained 2.2ppts since summer 2015
The grouping that has experienced the biggest growth in its collective market share is the top seven, with an increase of 2.2 ppts from 53.3% in summer 2015 to 55.5% this summer.
Since then, a more distinct top seven has emerged. In summer 2018 there is a bigger gap between Aeroflot in seventh place, with close to 4% of seats, and Norwegian, now in eighth place with a 3% share.
Meanwhile, Air Berlin Group has disappeared and SAS has slipped to ninth place.
Europe: top seven airline groups seat share, summer 2018
Europe's aviation market is much less concentrated than North America's
It is informative to compare Europe's airline market structure with that of North America, which is the world's most concentrated aviation region.
However, although the seat shares of the seventh and eighth ranked North American groups closely match the equivalent groups in Europe, the North American top seven collectively have an 81.8% share, compared with the European top seven's 55.5%.
The top five in North America have 73.6%, versus 46.1% in Europe, and the North American top three have 54.3%, compared with 31.7% in Europe.
Europe and North America: seat share of top 20, top 10, top seven, top five and top three airline groups, summer 2018
North America's four biggest airline groups are much larger than their European counterparts
Within the top seven in each continent, only the number seven airline groups have a similar seat share of approximately 4% in each region.
Above that, the European number five (easyJet) and number six (Turkish Airlines) actually have a higher share than their North American counterparts. EasyJet's 7% share compares with Air Canada's 5%, and Turkish Airlines' 6% compares with Alaska Air Group's 5%.
However, it is among the top four in each region that North American airline groups have a much higher seat share. No European group in the top seven has a seat share as high as any North American top four group.
At number one, American Airlines has 19%, versus Lufthansa Group's 12%. Number two Delta's 18% significantly outweighs Ryanair's 10%, third placed Southwest's 17% compares with IAG's 9%, and number four United's 15% is more than double Air France-KLM's 7% share.
Moreover, each of the North American top four is bigger by seat numbers than its European counterpart. For example, American Airlines has 30% more seats than Lufthansa Group this summer, while United has 65% more seats than Air France-KLM.
Europe and North America: top seven airline groups seat share, summer 2018
An IAG/Norwegian deal would not take Europe's market structure much closer to North America's
If IAG were to acquire Norwegian and its 3% share of seats in Europe, this would just take the expanded IAG to the top of the European ranking by seats, with a share of 12% (to be more precise, it would be 12.24% – very slightly ahead of Lufthansa Group's 12.17%).
See related report: IAG and Norwegian Air begin to tango
This would be one of the biggest mergers/acquisitions in Europe for several years.
When IAG acquired Vueling in 2013 the Spanish LCC had approximately 2% of seats to/from/within Europe, while its 2015 acquisition of Aer Lingus brought with it a share of 1%. Lufthansa's 2018 full consolidation of Brussels Airlines took on the Belgian airline's share of less than 1%.
IAG has been the most active force in European airline consolidation since the wave of mega-mergers. Moreover, it has showed some imagination with its acquisitions, in terms of nationality and business model.
However, as with its Vueling and Aer Lingus purchases, an IAG/Norwegian deal would not really make a huge difference to overall market concentration.
It would take the top three from 31.7% to 34.7%, the top five from 46.1% to 49.1% and the top seven from 55.5% to 58.5%. In all instances, these figures would still be well short of the equivalent numbers in North America.
Only mergers between Europe's biggest groups could match North America's leading players
In order to synthesise a seat share similar to the 19% held in North America by American Airlines, Europe would need a merger such as Lufthansa Group with Air France-KLM, Ryanair with IAG, or Lufthansa Group with easyJet.
The only possible combinations of groups from Europe's top seven that would have a seat share greater than American's 19% would be Lufthansa Group with Ryanair or Lufthansa Group with IAG.
The 18% share held by Delta could be created in Europe by the merger of Lufthansa Group and Turkish Airlines. Southwest's 17% share would be matched by a combination of Ryanair with easyJet and almost matched by merging Lufthansa Group with Aeroflot or IAG with Air France-KLM.
To achieve a European group with a similar seat share to United's 15% would require the merger of Ryanair with Aeroflot, IAG with Turkish Airlines, or Air France-KLM with easyJet, (or Lufthansa Group with ninth placed SAS).
European consolidation is slow. It may be time to think the unthinkable
There could arguably be some cold industrial logic behind many of these hypothetical combinations, but the heat of opposition on political, labour relations and cultural grounds makes them virtually unthinkable in most of the above examples (although Lufthansa/SAS may be more thinkable).
There could also be concerns about such mega-deals on competition grounds. Although such big market shares exist in North America as a result of mergers in that market, this is no guarantee of acceptance by regulators in Europe.
Europe's fragmented market and lower profitability by comparison with North America suggest significant scope for further consolidation.
See related reports:
- European airline consolidation and profitability Part 1: top 5 airline groups have only 43% share
- European airline consolidation part 2: M and A potential of major groups; benefits and hurdles
- Europe LCC consolidation: 2nd-tier LCCs, legacy groups more likely to combine than Ryanair, easyJet
This is an ongoing, but slow, process in Europe and will likely be driven as much, or more, by market exits as by significant M&A activity.
However, there are some strong, well capitalised groups at the top end of the market that could afford to stimulate this process with big acquisitions. The time may be ripening for thinking the unthinkable in European airline consolidation.