US domestic aviation market: mature, but new opportunities arising
Despite a certain level of maturity, route development in the US continues to evolve.
The three largest US global network airlines are largely focused on leveraging the strength of their hubs, but Delta Air Lines has also built up a smaller group of focus cities during the past couple of years: in Raleigh/Durham, Cincinnati (a former hub) and Boston, which is a stronghold for JetBlue.
Delta's continued build-up in the market could prove to be a challenge for JetBlue in Boston, which is the airline's largest focus city by departing frequencies (as of late Feb-2019).
In 2019 the US ULCCs Spirit and Frontier are making a push from Delta's Raleigh focus city, after Frontier's market share at the airport reached nearly 6% in 2018. Spirit is also the first US ULCC to enter Charlotte, where American is the dominant airline by a wide margin. American has already responded to Spirit's mild market entry by adding capacity to the markets where Spirit plans to launch services.
None of those developments are earth shattering; but they do reflect a level of posturing that remains in the the US, despite four airlines dominating the market.
- Delta Air Lines is building up focus cities in Raleigh/Durham, Cincinnati, and Boston, which could pose a challenge for JetBlue in Boston.
- US ULCCs Spirit and Frontier are expanding in Delta's focus city of Raleigh, with Spirit also entering the market in Charlotte, challenging American Airlines.
- American Airlines is converting gates at its Dallas/Fort Worth hub to regional gates and adding 100 daily flights, while also adding gates in Charlotte to compete with Spirit.
- United Airlines is increasing capacity and rebanking hubs in Chicago O'Hare, Houston Intercontinental, and Denver to strengthen connections and improve revenues.
- Spirit Airlines is banking on connecting traffic from Charlotte through Fort Lauderdale and Orlando to its growing network in the Caribbean and Latin America.
- Delta's growth in Boston, with plans to launch services to key business destinations, poses a threat to JetBlue's dominance in the city.
Summary
- The large US global network airlines are largely focusing on leveraging their hubs, but Delta has also singled out three focus cities where it intends to build up a strong presence.
- Even as the majors work to maximise their presence at large hubs - and in Delta's case, its focus cities - US ULCCs continue to expand in those markets.
American and United work to maximise their strength in domestic hubs
With American, Delta, United and Southwest representing nearly 77% of US domestic ASKs, there are not huge network shifts in the market; however as that maturity level grows, operators are working to carve out new opportunities toward ultimately strengthening their revenues.
United States percentage of domestic ASKs by airline, as of late Feb-2019
Among the three large global network airlines, their respective network strategies are fairly clear cut - build up their hubs to maximise connections in order to bolster their revenues.
During the last couple of years United has opted to increase its capacity at higher levels than its peers to strengthen its competitiveness in the US market, and has rebanked hubs in Chicago O'Hare and Houston Intercontinental to strengthen connections. The airline is currently in the process of rebanking its Denver hub.
Although the strategy initially drew some criticism from Wall Street, for now it seems to be producing favourable results. United's 4Q2018 domestic passenger revenue per available seat mile (PRASM) jumped a healthy 6% year-on-year, driven by stronger close-in yields and business traffic.
This year American Airlines is in the process of converting nine mainline gates at its largest hub - Dallas/Fort Worth - to 15 regional gates (according to the Dallas Morning News) and is adding 100 daily flights from the airport. Some of the airline's new routes planned from DFW in 2019 include Augusta, Georgia; Bakersfield, Burbank and Monterey (seasonal), California; Yuma, Arizona; Gainesville, Florida; and Flagstaff, Arizona. American serves many of those routes - Yuma, Flagstaff, Monterey and Burbank - from its hub in Phoenix, but the airline has obviously concluded that it can reap solid yields on those routes from DFW as well.
American adds new gates in Charlotte as Spirit enters the market
At Charlotte Douglas International airport, where American has a 90.5% share of system wide ASKs, the airline is adding four gates near the end of 2019. In 2019 American is facing new competition from the ULCC Spirit Airlines at Charlotte, an airport that presently only has ULCC service from Mexico's Volaris, which offers flights to Guadalajara from the airport.
Spirit is launching once daily service from Charlotte to BWI (served by American and Southwest), Fort Lauderdale, (served by American) Orlando International (served by American and Frontier) and Newark (served by American and United). American has subsequently declared that it was adding more flights to those destinations, as well as Chicago, Los Angeles and New York JFK.
Even as Spirit seems to pose a minor threat to American at Charlotte, American has previously declared that Charlotte, Washington National and Dallas/Fort Worth produce higher margins than its other hubs (which include Phoenix, Philadelphia and Miami).
Obviously, American wants to ensure its margin integrity in those hubs and is flexing some muscle in Charlotte as Spirit enters the market.
American Airlines top ten hubs/bases/stations by departing frequencies, as of late Feb-2019
Spirit and Frontier join Delta in building up Raleigh-Durham
Spirit is banking on some connecting traffic from Charlotte through Fort Lauderdale and Orlando to its growing network in the Caribbean and Latin America. During 2018 Spirit launched a raft of new international markets from Orlando, and has stated that there are connecting opportunities to international destinations from the airport.
See related report: Spirit & Frontier Airlines in 2019: contrast in int'l expansion
The airline has some banking structures at its largest base in Fort Lauderdale, but for now connections represent just a fraction of its operations. However, Spirit appears to be calculating that some customers will flow over Fort Lauderdale and Orlando from Charlotte to its growing network in Latin America and the Caribbean.
Spirit is also adding Raleigh Durham and Austin as new markets in 2019, and the ULCC Frontier is also capping off a push from Raleigh.
Delta Air Lines has been building up Raleigh as a focus city during the past couple of years and holds a 27% ASK share at the airport as of late Feb-2019, as well as 35% of its departing frequencies.
Raleigh-Durham International percentage of departing frequencies by airline, as of late Feb-2019
Despite the welcome build-up by Delta, for a few years Raleigh was working to secure service from Spirit, assuming that the airline's presence would expand its market and draw new customers.
Spirit's fellow ULCC Frontier made a push from Raleigh-Durham in 2018, with growth of 173% in enplaned passengers year-on-year.
Frontier also attained a 5.8% market share at the airport in 2018, which no doubt caught Spirit's attention. Frontier is also adding seven additional new routes from Raleigh-Durham in 2019, which should further expand its market share at the airport.
Through Frontier's expansion, and with Spirit's market entry, the airport will have a solid ULCC presence.
See related report: Raleigh Durham International airport: a ULCC growth surge in 2019
Delta could prove to be a thorn in JetBlue's side at Boston Logan International
In addition to Raleigh Durham, Delta has focused on focus cities in Boston and Cincinnati (a former hub) during the past couple of years. Before its build-up in Raleigh, Delta had concluded that it was a fast growing city with bright economic prospects, and no airline had a 15% share of the market there. In 2018, Delta's market share in Raleigh-Durham was 30.7%.
That thesis does not apply in Boston, where JetBlue holds a nearly 32% share of departing frequencies and has ambitions to grow its daily departures at the airport to 200.
During 2018 JetBlue did cite some unit revenue pressure on Boston leisure routes "tied to growth from a legacy airline", but concluded that those trends were improving sequentially and stressed that, given Boston's geographic location, it was made for an airline that specialises in point-to-point service.
Still, Delta's growth in Boston continues unabated as it prepares to launch services to four key business destinations in 2019: Chicago O'Hare, Newark, Washington National and Cleveland. The Boston Globe has reported that Delta is aiming to grow its daily departures from 110 to 144, which shows that it will continue to challenge JetBlue's dominance in Boston and compete fiercely for the corporate accounts that JetBlue has worked to capture.
US operators are working to create opportunities in a consolidated market
As the US market settles and continues to digest the consolidation that has taken place during the past couple of decades, operators in the market are still working to make their own opportunities in the market place.
These results of those efforts, as well as the winners and losers, should emerge during the next couple of years.